At a recent tour stop in Boston on Saturday (Jan. 26), Garth Brooks brought out a surprise guest for a performance of “More Than a Memory.” It was Lee Brice, who wrote the song, and Brooks took it to No. 1 back in 2007. This was Brice’s very first hit as a songwriter.

After the show, the guys had a love fest on twitter:

Bucket list…check…Holy crap…I just sang with @garthbrooks in Boston! #BostonStrong #ThankYouGarth

— Lee Brice (@leebrice) January 25, 2015

@leebrice Lee, can’t thank you enough for making the late Saturday show so special! Boston loves you and you deserve it! love you, pal, g

— Garth Brooks (@garthbrooks) January 25, 2015